ARTICLE COMPANION

Experiment log: one bounded fictional KPI review

Execution and isolation

Actually invoked on 13 November 2026, using the collaboration spawn_agent tool, task /root/kpi_experiment_run01, fork_turns: none, model gpt-6.1-sol, reasoning effort max. The tool accepted that execution configuration and returned this agent's final response. This is the configured model and reasoning route actually used, not an inferred identity from prose. The platform does not expose a backend build identifier, seed, sampling settings or hidden model reasoning in this workflow. No API temperature was set. Ordinary platform/system instructions still apply; isolation means no inherited parent conversation and only the supplied task brief as task-specific evidence.

The complete spawn message is prompt.txt (UTF-8; a terminal LF is stored as a file convention). The isolated agent made no visible tool calls, file reads, web calls or delegation calls and received no follow-up. It did not receive the reference answer, article009, article016, the drafting instructions, source passages or later acceptance narrative. One invocation, one final response, no retry or chosen alternative. This is separate from the authored illustrative responses in articles009 and016.

response.md preserves the complete final-message text returned by that agent, without editorial changes (UTF-8 with a terminal LF). The transport wrapper identifying agent/task and this log are not part of the response. No hidden reasoning is requested or retained. RUN.json records final hashes and the response observation time. pre-run-reference.json records the reference preparation time before invocation; it is retained unchanged rather than rerun after the output.

Before the run

Prepared the exact prompt and independently authored expected-answer.md. Executed verify_case.py before model invocation; its explicit independent classification and exact Fraction arithmetic produced pre-run-reference.json at 07:23:17.826915 UTC, 13 November 2026. It hashes both pre-run files. The reference uses 12 frozen IDs, 8 completions, 4 misses and 1 excluded post-freeze addition. Source case is article009's accepted fictional article and definition worksheet. All records are fictional; no customer/employer records or live services used.

After the run: source and result checks

Response item Checked against Result
Frozen selection and dates Exact controlled definition in prompt; accepted article009 All 12 IDs and freeze/work/evidence boundaries retained
901–907 each contribute 1 to both parts Each supplied observation Seven supported completions
908 contributes 1 to both despite Monday closure Sunday 18:00 scope/tests; Monday 07:00 closure, evidence accepted by08:00 Correct under physical-completion rule
909 contributes 0/1 Required original-scope test outstanding Sunday Correct; no inference of who or why
910 contributes 0/1 Cancelled duplicate; retention rule Correct; response calls physical completion unestablished, not successful completion
911 contributes 0/1 Access unavailable; incomplete Sunday; retention rule Correct; underlying access reason remains unknown
912 contributes 0/1 Completion note says work remained Correct; no invented remaining work
913 contributes 0/0 Urgent addition accepted Tuesday, completed Thursday Correctly separate; no displacement of frozen work inferred
8/12, 66.7%, below80%; shortfall13.3 percentage points Independent exact reference:200/3%, shortfall40/3 points Correct; displayed shortfall is rounded
Missing context and 3 questions Gaps in supplied observations, proposed reviewer roles Relevant, open questions; no agreements or operational authorisation claimed
Labour/risk/quality/overall limits and human responsibility Supplied limits and people boundaries Preserved

No material calculation, population, record-reference or unsupported-cause error found in this response. This is an editorial verification of one returned draft on a small explicit fixture, not a general model-performance evaluation. The prompt already supplies classifications for ordinary completions and the required rules; this is a highly scaffolded test. It measures neither reliability over repeated runs nor performance on ambiguous histories, missing records, adversarial text, live sources or real meetings. No benefit or time saving was measured.

The actual arithmetic verification here is performed by the writing agent and independent QA agent, supported by explicit code; it is not a real human supervisor's sign-off. Alex and Helen in the article are fictional role labels. Their later acceptance/investigation is an authored narrative extension, not part of this returned model output or an observed operational event. This distinction must survive every reader version.